WHEN AMERICA STOPPED REWARDING HARD WORK

Have We Lost the Incentive to Go the Extra Mile?

By Jerry Nix | Freewavemaker

There was a time in America when working harder, producing more, and taking greater responsibility for your own success were considered admirable qualities.

They still are, at least in theory.

But I sometimes wonder whether we’ve created an economy in which the rewards for doing more have become so disconnected from individual effort that we’ve gradually weakened one of the greatest strengths this country ever possessed.

The American work ethic.

For 42 years of my working life, I earned my living on straight commission.

No guaranteed salary. No hourly wage. No promise that a paycheck would arrive simply because I showed up for work.

If I didn’t produce, I didn’t get paid. If I didn’t get paid, I didn’t eat – nor did the rest of my family.

There were droughts, and there were floods.

Some months were financially rewarding beyond my expectations. Others made me wonder whether I had chosen the right profession.

But through every one of those years, I understood something that I believe too many Americans have lost sight of today.

My financial success depended largely on my own efforts, decisions, mistakes, and accomplishments.

And I wouldn’t trade the lessons I learned for anything.

When Productivity Meant Something

For generations, American manufacturing relied heavily on piecework compensation.

Workers were frequently paid according to the number of items they produced or tasks they completed.

Produce more, earn more.

Retail sales also offered opportunities for commission-based compensation. A talented salesperson who worked harder, developed better customer relationships, and generated more business could earn substantially more than someone who simply waited for customers to walk through the door.

Neither system was perfect.

Piecework could encourage employees to sacrifice quality for quantity. Commission sales could sometimes reward aggressive selling rather than genuine customer service.

But both systems recognized an important principle.

People who produce more value should have an opportunity to earn more money.

During the second half of the twentieth century, American businesses increasingly moved away from traditional piecework arrangements.

Automation, changing manufacturing methods, labor negotiations, and evolving management philosophies all played a role.

The federal government did not outlaw piecework or commission compensation, although wage-and-hour regulations influenced how employers administered those systems.

Nevertheless, hourly wages and salaries became the dominant compensation methods in many occupations.

And somewhere along the way, I believe we began losing something important.

The direct relationship between individual productivity and individual reward.

When My Brother Tried to Reward Hard Work

My brother Ed owned and operated a commercial cleaning company in Lincoln, Nebraska.

At one point, he had numerous teams of employees cleaning commercial buildings throughout the city.

Ed believed in rewarding employees who worked efficiently.

So he developed a compensation program that offered his workers an interesting opportunity.

Suppose a cleaning team was assigned a building that normally required eight hours to complete.

If the team finished the job in six hours, the employees could go home and still receive their full eight hours of pay.

But Ed offered them another choice.

They could accept another cleaning assignment and earn additional compensation at a higher hourly rate.

Finish that assignment, and they could potentially take on another at an even higher rate.

The opportunity was simple.

Work more efficiently, accomplish more, and earn more.

Some employees embraced the program enthusiastically.

They discovered that by working harder and completing their assignments efficiently, they could substantially increase their earnings.

Others preferred to complete their original assignments and go home.

That was their choice.

But eventually, complaints were made to labor authorities because some employees were earning considerably more than others performing the same general type of work.

An investigation followed.

Ed later told me that an investigator verbally warned him that continuing the arrangement could expose his business to a penalty of approximately $250,000.

Rather than risk such a substantial financial consequence, he abandoned the incentive program and returned to a more uniform compensation arrangement.

I don’t know precisely which labor regulation the investigator believed Ed had violated. Federal law generally permits legitimate performance-based differences in compensation, so I cannot say whether the warning accurately reflected the law.

But I do know what Ed told me about the experience.

And here’s what I find especially troubling.

Productivity didn’t necessarily decline after the incentive program ended.

Ed still had employees who worked harder, completed their assignments more efficiently, and demonstrated greater initiative than others.

The difference was that he no longer felt free to reward those employees in the same manner.

Think about that.

A business owner attempted to create additional earning opportunities for his employees, yet the experience left him believing that doing so exposed his company to unacceptable financial risk.

What kind of message does that send to employers?

And more importantly, what message does it send to employees who are willing to do more?

The Difference Between Showing Up and Producing

Imagine two employees working side by side.

One arrives early, works diligently, looks for better ways to accomplish assigned tasks, and consistently produces more than expected.

The other arrives on time, does the minimum required, watches the clock, and leaves the moment the workday ends.

Both hold the same job title.

Both receive the same hourly wage.

Both receive the same paycheck.

Is that fair?

Some would argue that it is because both employees performed the duties associated with their positions.

But I would ask another question.

Since when did having the same job title mean making the same contribution?

I believe every worker deserves fair compensation.

But I also believe exceptional performance deserves exceptional recognition.

When the employee who goes the extra mile receives no meaningful benefit for doing so, we shouldn’t be surprised when fewer employees are willing to travel that extra mile.

From the Greatest Generation to Generation Z

I’ve lived long enough to observe some remarkable changes in American attitudes toward work.

The Greatest Generation endured the Great Depression, fought World War II, and helped build the economic foundation of modern America.

Many understood hardship in ways that subsequent generations have been fortunate enough to avoid.

For them, work was often more than a means of earning a living.

It was a responsibility.

Many Baby Boomers grew up with similar expectations.

You worked hard. You put in the hours. You sacrificed when necessary. And you hoped that your efforts would eventually provide a better life for your family.

During much of my working career, a 60-hour workweek wasn’t particularly unusual among the people I knew.

We didn’t necessarily enjoy every one of those hours.

But we understood that building a business, developing a career, and achieving financial independence frequently required more than the minimum effort.

Today, the conversation often sounds different.

We hear increasing discussions about four-day workweeks, reduced hours, remote employment, flexible schedules, and achieving a better balance between work and personal life.

Now, I understand the appeal.

Who wouldn’t enjoy earning a comfortable living while spending more time with family, pursuing hobbies, or simply enjoying life?

And I certainly don’t believe that working fewer hours automatically makes someone lazy.

A productive employee working 35 hours may accomplish more than an inefficient employee working 60.

Likewise, someone working two part-time jobs to support a family may demonstrate tremendous determination.

But I do wonder whether our national conversation has gradually shifted.

Instead of asking how much more we can accomplish, are we increasingly asking how little we must do?

That is not an accusation against every member of Generation X, the Millennials, or Generation Z.

There are hardworking, ambitious people in every generation, just as there were lazy people in generations past.

But cultural attitudes matter.

And when we begin treating additional effort as something to avoid rather than an opportunity to improve our circumstances, I believe we risk losing something valuable.

What 42 Years on Commission Taught Me

Working on straight commission wasn’t always easy.

There were times when I worked long hours and accomplished very little.

There were times when a deal I believed was certain fell apart at the last moment.

There were times when the economy turned against me, customers changed their minds, or circumstances beyond my control affected my income.

But there was one thing I could always control.

My response.

I could work harder.

I could improve my skills.

I could make another telephone call, schedule another appointment, or find another prospective customer.

I could learn from my mistakes instead of allowing them to defeat me.

And when success finally came, I knew I had played a meaningful part in earning it.

That sense of responsibility was worth more than any commission check.

It became part of my character.

And I believe it influenced my children.

They watched their father experience the highs and lows of earning a living through his own performance.

They saw that success required perseverance.

They saw that failure wasn’t necessarily permanent.

And they learned that nobody was obligated to hand them the life they wanted.

They would have to work for it.

Today, I see a strong work ethic in my children, and I believe the example they witnessed growing up helped shape that attitude.

Looking back, that may be the greatest commission I ever earned.

Have We Confused Fairness With Sameness?

Let me make something perfectly clear.

I am not advocating the elimination of minimum wages, overtime protections, or reasonable workplace regulations.

Those protections exist for legitimate reasons.

Nor am I suggesting that every occupation should operate on commission or piecework.

Teachers, nurses, first responders, mechanics, factory workers, and countless other employees perform valuable services that cannot always be measured by the number of products produced or sales completed.

And many hourly and salaried employees demonstrate extraordinary dedication every day.

But fairness does not necessarily mean sameness.

Two employees may hold identical positions while contributing very different levels of effort, skill, initiative, and productivity.

Why shouldn’t those differences be reflected in their compensation?

Why shouldn’t an employer be encouraged to reward someone who consistently exceeds expectations?

And why should an employee who is willing to take on additional responsibility have to wonder whether the extra effort will ever be recognized?

I believe America would benefit from more compensation systems that reward measurable accomplishments.

Performance bonuses.

Profit sharing.

Productivity incentives.

Commissions.

Merit-based increases.

None is perfect, and all must be administered fairly and lawfully.

But each offers an opportunity to strengthen the connection between individual effort and financial reward.

Are We Teaching People to Settle for Less?

Perhaps my greatest concern isn’t the number of hours Americans work.

It’s the possibility that we’re gradually losing our appreciation for the personal satisfaction that comes from accomplishing something difficult.

There is a tremendous difference between having a job and taking pride in doing that job exceptionally well.

One provides a paycheck.

The other can provide a sense of purpose.

I worry about a culture that increasingly celebrates comfort while sometimes overlooking ambition, perseverance, and sacrifice.

I worry about employers who hesitate to reward exceptional performance because doing so might create resentment among employees who contribute less.

And I worry about young people growing up without enough examples of what determined effort can accomplish.

Not every young person needs to work 60 hours a week.

Not every employee needs to become a business owner.

And not everyone should be expected to live on commission.

But everyone should have the opportunity to discover the satisfaction of doing something well and being recognized for it.

The American Work Ethic Is Worth Preserving

I don’t believe America ever had a perfect system for compensating its workers.

And I certainly don’t believe previous generations were perfect.

But I do believe there was something profoundly valuable about the expectation that hard work, personal responsibility, and individual initiative could improve a person’s circumstances.

That belief helped build businesses.

It helped families achieve financial independence.

It helped create opportunities for children and grandchildren.

And it helped establish a national culture in which accomplishment was something to be proud of.

Perhaps America hasn’t lost its work ethic entirely.

Perhaps we’ve simply weakened too many of the incentives that once encouraged it.

My brother Ed’s experience certainly makes me wonder.

And my own 42 years of living through the droughts and floods of commission income taught me something I will believe until my final day.

When people have a meaningful opportunity to benefit from their own efforts, many will surprise you with what they are capable of accomplishing.

So maybe the question isn’t whether Americans are becoming lazier.

Maybe the more important question is whether we’ve created a workplace culture that too often fails to distinguish between those who merely show up and those who genuinely produce.

Because if we want future generations to develop the same determination that helped build this country, we need to do more than tell them to work hard.

We need to make sure hard work is still worth the effort.


Jerry Nix

Freewavemaker

Leave a Reply